Lyle Denniston

Mar 3 2015

States want immigration policy kept on hold

Twenty-six states that had persuaded a federal judge last month to delay the Obama administration’s new policy on deferring deportation of more than four million undocumented immigrants argued on Tuesday that there was no emergency, so no need to let the policy go into effect.

The filing  in a federal trial court in Brownsville, Texas, urged the judge to reject a Justice Department plea to put his ruling on hold while it challenges it in an appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.

Under the judge’s ruling, the states contended, the government can still use its discretion about which immigrants to order deported, or which to allow a right to remain in the country.  All that it is barred from doing, they said, is granting new benefits, like work permits and drivers’ licenses, plus the special benefit of officislly designated “legal presence” in the U.S.   Only Congress could do that, the judge found, and the states asked him to make sure those benefits do not go forward.

The judge is expected to act quickly, probably setting the stage for the Justice Department to move on up in the appeal process.  It seems likely that the issue of the timing of the new policy could wind up in the Supreme Court.

Lyle Denniston continues to write about the U.S. Supreme Court, although he “retired” at the end of 2019 following more than six decades on that news beat. He was there for three revolutions – civil rights, women’s rights, and gay rights – and the start of a fourth, on transgender rights. His career of following the law began at the Otoe County Courthouse in his hometown, Nebraska City, Nebraska, in the fall of 1948. His online, eight-week, college-level course – “The Supreme Court and American Politics” – is available from the University of Baltimore Law School, and it is free.

Recent Posts

  • Trump’s power to deport curbed
  • How will the Court rule on citizenship?
  • Will Trump fire the Fed chief?
  • Court steps into historic citizenship dispute
  • Is President Trump defying the Supreme Court?
Site built and optimized by Sound Strategies